LanBulo
← Back to LanBulo

How to choose a yarn substitute

The yarn a pattern calls for may be discontinued, too expensive or simply not sold near you. A good substitute gives you the same gauge, a similar fabric and enough yardage to finish. Here is what to compare — the same factors LanBulo uses to rank alternatives by match percentage.

What to compare (and how much it matters)

When a yarn is missing some details, LanBulo scores it on what is known and lowers its score slightly, so well-documented yarns rank higher.

Step by step

  1. Look up the pattern yarn's weight category, meterage per skein and fiber blend.
  2. Shortlist yarns in the same weight category with similar meterage per gram.
  3. Prefer a similar fiber blend, then check the recommended gauge and needle or hook size.
  4. Work out how much you need: total metres in the pattern ÷ metres per skein of the new yarn, rounded up.
  5. Swatch, wash the swatch, and adjust your needle or hook until you match the pattern's gauge.

Other useful filters

LanBulo lets you hide discontinued yarns, prefer certain fibers and set a minimum community rating from Ravelry users. You can also search descriptively, for example "100% linen dk" or "merino not superwash". No single yarn fits? The By gauge & combos tab suggests holding two strands together to reach the gauge you need.

Swapping yarn without guessing

A "worsted" label tells you very little. Compare how much length you get per gram, then check the result with a washed swatch.

meters or yards — same unit for both yarns

Yarn in the pattern
Yarn you want to use
Total length needed
1,000
before the buffer
Skeins to buy
5
Total weight to buy (g): 500
Thickness difference
10%
thinner than the original

Close match. Swatch to confirm the gauge.

The sample numbers are an example. Replace them with the figures from your two yarn labels. Always compare length, not weight, because a cotton and a wool skein of the same grams can differ by a lot.

How to read the label

  • Divide length by weight for each yarn. A higher number means a thinner yarn.
  • Within 10% of the original is a safe starting point. Between 10% and 20%, expect to change needle size. Beyond 20%, you have a different weight of yarn and the pattern's gauge will not hold.
  • Match the gauge in the pattern (stitches per 10 cm), not the weight name on the band.

When the fiber changes too

Wool to wool

What changes: Small changes in bounce and halo from breed and ply.

What to do: Swatch, and go by gauge.

Wool to cotton or linen

What changes: Heavier, no stretch, and it lengthens as you wear it.

What to do: Hang the washed swatch overnight to see the growth. Consider a smaller needle and a slightly shorter body.

Wool to alpaca or silk blend

What changes: More drape, less memory, and it grows.

What to do: Go down a needle size and avoid steam on the longest parts.

Wool to acrylic

What changes: Lighter and less warm, with less shape memory.

What to do: Block with water only. Skip steam.

Cotton or linen to wool

What changes: More bounce and warmth, and it holds fitted shapes better.

What to do: Check ease for a fitted garment, and expect a softer drape.

Superwash and non-superwash

What changes: Superwash is limper and grows. The other felts if washed wrong.

What to do: Match the care label to how you will wash the finished piece.

Before you commit

  • Knit a swatch at least 15 cm square, then wash and block it exactly as you will the finished piece. Measure after drying.
  • If the gauge is off, change the needle size and leave the stitch counts alone.
  • Buy every skein from one dye lot, and add extra for stripes, colorwork or length changes.
  • Check twist and plies too. Loosely plied yarn shows cables less sharply than a tight, round yarn.

Ready to find your substitute?

Type the yarn your pattern uses and get alternatives ranked by match %.

Find yarn alternatives

Yarn data comes from Ravelry. LanBulo is independent and not affiliated with Ravelry.